"This world of ours appears to be separated by a slight and precarious margin of safety from a most singular and unexpected danger." — Arthur Conan Doyle, "The Horror of the Heights" (1913)
New York's arts council and its partner foundation announced $1.76 million in grants to 59 arts organizations on October 20, and under the program's guidelines the money must go toward a reserve. Four-fifths of each grant is released only after the organization's board adopts a written reserve policy and the foundation approves it; the rest follows a final report.
Last week's issue was about organizations that ran out of runway. This one is about who pays to build it: a funder that pays nothing until the board has adopted a policy and the funder has approved it, county committees that approved a lease whose draft leaves the roof with the county, and a movie palace whose fundraiser hopes for a $22 million endowment to help pay for upkeep.
This week:
- A funder that will pay nonprofits to save, once each board adopts a reserve policy and the funder approves it.
- A $1 lease of a county building whose draft leaves the roof with the county.
- A century-old theater whose fundraiser hopes for an endowment to help pay for upkeep.
- The FCC's opt-out rule for automated texts, effective November 25.
- The IRS's 2027 numbers for donor thank-you gifts and staff benefits.
- A prompt that maps where donors meet your software.
- A prompt that decides where a person has to sign off on what AI produces.
- A board exercise that prices your next big repair. And
- A column on the money nobody thanks you for raising.
New York Announced $1.76 Million for 59 Arts Nonprofits to Put in Reserve. Each Board Has to Adopt a Reserve Policy Before Any of It Arrives.
Grants usually pay for something a funder can photograph. This one pays for money that sits still.
On October 20, according to a copy of the release posted by one of the grantees, the New York State Council on the Arts and the New York Foundation for the Arts announced the second year of their Reserve Fund Grants: $1,760,000 to 59 organizations, chosen from 771 eligible applications. Grants run from $15,000 to $50,000, scaled to budget, and the program is open to arts nonprofits with budgets between $150,000 and $3 million that the council has funded directly in the past three years.
The release says eighty percent of this year's recipients "will be establishing a reserve fund for the first time."
The design is in the foundation's published guidelines, and it is the part to copy. The funds "must be used towards stabilizing the organization's budget" by starting a reserve or adding to one. The board "must adopt a Reserve Policy," due to the foundation by March 1, 2027.
No money moves until the foundation approves the policy. Then four-fifths of the grant is released. The organization then has to show that this first installment sat, in full, in an interest-bearing account for at least three consecutive months.
The rest follows a final report.
The guidelines also say what a reserve policy is: a board-approved document that sets out what the reserve is for, the conditions and limits for drawing on it, and how it gets refilled.
So the funder is buying two things. One is a cushion. The other is a board vote on the rules for touching it, a vote that an organization with no reserve has never needed to take.
One recipient shows what the grant is and is not. Hudson Hall, which runs an 1855 opera house in Hudson, New York, is to receive $45,000 "to seed its first-ever Reserve Fund," NYS Music reported on October 28. The same article says Hudson Hall has finished a campaign begun in 2021 and retired the $3 million debt left from a $9.5 million renovation completed in 2017, with the Reinhart Foundation, which had earlier put up a $500,000 one-to-one match, covering the remainder this year.
"That means more of our resources can go toward the work we're here to do," executive director Adam Weinert said.
The tax filings show the direction, though the latest one ends before the payoff. Total liabilities, which include more than the loan, fell from $5.2 million in June 2017 to $835,000 in June 2025.
They also show the limits. Hudson Hall spent $1.65 million in the year ending June 2025 and took in $1.25 million, its second straight deficit.
Against that spending, $45,000 is about ten days. A first reserve is a start and a habit. Nobody should mistake it for a runway.
What you can take from New York depends on which chair you sit in.
If you fund nonprofits, the structure costs little to borrow: a modest grant, a board-adopted policy as the condition of payment, a holding period, and some coaching. The program offers each grantee a workshop, a one-hour session and monthly office hours with a consulting firm.
If you run a nonprofit, you can set the same condition for yourself. Have the board adopt a written reserve policy. Then ask one donor for a gift to start the reserve, and hand over the policy with the request.
The record here is thin in two places. I could not open the council's own release; the figures come from a grantee's copy of it and from the foundation's guidelines. And the Hudson Hall payoff rests on one outlet's account of the organization's announcement, with no lender, payoff date or interest figure given.
Sources: New York Foundation for the Arts, NYSCA Reserve Fund Grants guidelines; NYSCA and NYFA release, October 20, 2026, as posted by the NYC Arts in Education Roundtable; NYFA, Reserve Fund Grants recipients; Olivia Hanson, "Hudson Hall Retires $3M Debt with Completion of Rise Up! Campaign," NYS Music, October 28, 2026; Hudson Hall, "Rise Up! Campaign Celebration" (2024); ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, Hudson Opera House Inc
County Committees in Wisconsin Approved a $1 Lease of a Former Campus Building to a New Nonprofit. In the Draft, the County Keeps the Roof for a Year.
When the University of Wisconsin–Stevens Point moved its Wausau branch onto a technical college's campus this fall, Marathon County was left with a 33,356-square-foot building, a 350-seat theater inside it, and a decision to make.
A local arts group had an answer. In July, WSAW reported that the group, Community Ambassadors Through Music, had proposed buying the building for $1 and had created a new corporation, the Marathon Center for Arts and Culture, to run it. By the group's own estimate the building would cost roughly $300,000 a year to operate, paid from fundraising, grants, office leases and theater rentals.
That is not the deal that went to a vote. On Thursday, November 5, county officials at a joint committee meeting approved a lease instead, WSAW reported, at a rent of $1.
The terms come from the draft lease as Wausau Pilot & Review described it four days before the vote. The lease runs January 1 through December 31, 2027. The nonprofit pays for utilities, janitorial service, routine maintenance and non-structural repairs, and carries at least $1 million in liability insurance.
The county stays responsible for the structure, the roof, the exterior, the plumbing, the electrical system, and heating and cooling, and it keeps the property insurance.
The sale is put off. A purchase agreement is to come before the committees and the full County Board in November or December 2027, with the transfer in January 2028. A default during the lease year, the draft says, as the Pilot & Review quoted it, "may affect Tenant's eligibility for the contemplated 2028 transfer."
Why the detour? The reason given is paperwork. The new nonprofit received its federal tax exemption this year, but it still has to complete state paperwork for a property-tax exemption, and a year of running the building, the Pilot & Review reported, would give it the numbers it needs.
"The lease allows the initial transition to occur with MCAC paying for all operational costs," the county's deputy administrator, Chris Holman, wrote in a memo quoted by the Pilot & Review.
I read a second benefit into it, and it is my reading, not the county's. A brand-new organization with no operating history gets twelve months to learn what the lights, the cleaning and the small repairs cost before it takes on the heating system. And the county gets twelve months to see whether its buyer can carry the place.
If someone offers your organization a building, this is the sequence worth asking for.
Lease first. Put in writing which systems are yours and which stay with the owner. Set the date on which ownership changes hands and the conditions for getting there.
One gap is worth more than the rest of the story. The memo, the Pilot & Review noted, "does not estimate what the county's repair obligations could cost next year."
Under the draft, the roof has a keeper for 2027. The memo does not say what keeping it might cost, and if the sale goes through in 2028, the question passes to the nonprofit.
The limits: the lease and the memo were not available to me, so every lease term above except the $1 rent is one newsroom's account of a draft. WSAW reported no vote count and did not say whether the full County Board must also act. No officer of the new nonprofit is quoted in either outlet's reports. The group had also asked the county to create an executive director position; the lease, the Pilot & Review reported, does not address it.
Sources: Ceara Hunsaker, "Arts non-profit to lease former campus building in Wausau," WSAW, November 5, 2026; Shereen Siewert, "Arts group would lease former UWSP at Wausau theater building for $1 in 2027, delaying sale to 2028," Wausau Pilot & Review, November 1, 2026; Heather Poltrock, "County in negotiations to sell theater building at former UW campus," WSAW, July 7, 2026
Tampa Theatre Reopened After the First Phase of Restoring a City-Owned Movie Palace. Its Fundraiser Hopes to Raise a $22 Million Endowment to Help Pay for Upkeep.
Tampa Theatre opened in 1926. In October it reopened after a seven-month restoration, the first phase of a longer campaign, and by October about $24.25 million had been raised toward that phase's $24.5 million goal, Tampa Bay Business & Wealth reported on November 4.
The building belongs to the City of Tampa. A nonprofit, Tampa Theatre Inc., manages it.
Capital campaigns tend to end at the ribbon. The plan Devin Dominguez describes does not. Dominguez, the theater's vice president and director of development, told the magazine that after the next round of construction she hopes to raise $22 million for an endowment whose earnings would help pay for maintenance.
"That's insurance," she said.
Her reasoning comes out of the restoration. She built a cushion into its budget, she said, because "I didn't want to go back to donors and say, 'Surprise, I need another $250,000.'" An endowment is that cushion made permanent. The magazine's arithmetic: if the fund spent 4 percent a year, $22 million would yield about $880,000.
And the repairs are not ordinary. "When the plaster breaks, it's not like you just call somebody down the street to come fix it," said George Levesque, the president and chief executive.
Could the theater cover its own upkeep out of ticket sales? Not on the latest filing. In the year ending September 2025, Tampa Theatre took in $6.68 million and spent $5.50 million, a surplus of about $1.2 million on paper.
But about $3.99 million of that income, 60 percent by my arithmetic, came from tickets and programs. Another $2.43 million came from gifts and grants, some of which, the magazine noted, may have been restricted.
Earned income alone fell about $1.5 million short of spending. A good year's surplus, with the gifts counted, is not a repair fund.
Dominguez's other line is the one I would put in front of a board: "Being a nonprofit is a tax status. It's not a business model."
There are two things here for an organization a tenth the size.
Name the upkeep while people are still looking at the new thing. If you are raising money for a roof, a van or a database, put a line for keeping it working into the same campaign, and say so to donors.
Dominguez is saying it within weeks of a reopening. Earlier is better still.
And know whose building it is. The city owns this one and a nonprofit runs it; what their agreement says about repairs is not public.
If you work in a building someone else owns, read what your own agreement says before you raise money to fix it. The Board Corner below is built for that.
Keep the record in proportion. The endowment is a hope: nothing has been reported as raised toward it, and it waits behind another construction phase. One magazine carries the plan and the quotations. How the restoration money divides between public and private sources has not been disclosed.
Sources: Chuck Merlis, "Tampa Theatre Makes the Economic Case for Nonprofit Movie Theaters," Tampa Bay Business & Wealth, November 4, 2026; Chuck Merlis, "Tampa Theatre names new CEO ahead of centennial," Tampa Bay Business & Wealth, April 17, 2026; Gabriella Paul, "Historic Tampa Theatre will raise the curtain on a $24.5 million restoration for centennial," WUSF, October 9, 2026; ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, Tampa Theatre Inc
From November 25 You May Name One Way for People to Opt Out of Your Automated Texts and Calls
In September this newsletter said to wait for the FCC's final rule before rewriting your text opt-out language. The rule was published October 26 and takes effect November 25.
If you send automated texts or recorded calls to people who agreed to get them, the rule lets you, the sender, name one exclusive way to say stop: a reply by text, a key press on a call, or a website or phone number you choose. The rule sets the reply words: stop, quit, end, revoke, opt out, cancel, unsubscribe.
Name a method, state it in every message, and the rule no longer obliges you to process requests that come some other way. Name none and you must keep honoring any reasonable request. Either way you have ten business days to stop messaging the person.
Action: Ask your texting vendor three things: whether your messages fall under the rule, whether the platform honors all seven reply words, and how you name reply-by-text as your one method on that platform.
If you choose reply-by-text, read your last three automated texts and confirm each says how, with one of the seven words, as in "Reply STOP to opt out." Then decide what happens to a request that arrives by email or phone. My advice: honor it anyway, and write down which staff member handles it.
ROI: A written opt-out practice, and a supporter who asked to stop and was heard.
Time: About 30 minutes, plus the vendor's reply.
Sources: Federal Communications Commission, "Enhancing the Ability of Consumers To Control the Robocalls," final rule, 91 FR 67214, October 26, 2026
The IRS Set the 2027 Numbers for Donor Thank-You Gifts: $14.33, $71.65 and $143.30
On November 5 the IRS published its 2027 inflation adjustments. Three of them decide when you may tell a donor a gift is fully deductible even though you sent a thank-you.
If your appeal tells donors how much of a gift is deductible, and the gift meets either of two tests, you may call it fully deductible. For 2027, the tests read this way.
One: the donor gives at least $71.65 and gets only items carrying your name or logo, such as a mug or a calendar, whose total cost to you is $14.33 or less.
Two: what the donor gets has a market value of no more than 2 percent of the gift, with a ceiling of $143.30. For 2026 the same three figures are $69.50, $13.90 and $139.
The same document sets staff benefit limits your payroll provider needs: health flexible spending accounts, $3,500, with a $700 carryover; commuter transit and parking, $350 a month each; and employer education assistance, $5,400, up from $5,250.
Action: Find where your thank-you letters or donor database decide what to call fully deductible. Change the three figures there on January 1, 2027, not before; gifts received in 2026 stay on the 2026 figures.
Check next year's thank-you items: for a donor at $71.65 or above, the logo items together should cost you no more than $14.33. Forward the staff benefit limits to whoever runs payroll before the first January pay date.
ROI: Acknowledgment letters that state the right deductible amount.
Time: About 20 minutes.
Sources: IRS, Revenue Procedure 2026-35; IRS, news release IR-2026-133, November 5, 2026; IRS, Revenue Procedure 90-12; IRS, Publication 1771, Charitable Contributions: Substantiation and Disclosure Requirements
Two surveys, and the pairing is mine, not theirs. Donors in one want to know when software is speaking for a charity. Adults in the other want a person checking AI's work in healthcare.
Each prompt turns one of those into a working page.
Map Every Place a Donor Meets Your Software
Copy and paste:
I work in fundraising at a nonprofit and I need an inventory before I change anything. In this message, after these instructions, I am pasting a plain description of every way we contact donors and every tool involved: our email platform, donation page, any chat window, text messages, thank-you letters and phone scripts, and, for each one, who or what writes it, whose name it goes out under, whether a person reads it before it goes out, whether and where the donor is told software is involved, which staff member is responsible, and how a donor reaches a person from there. Build a table with one row per contact point and five columns: what the donor sees; whether any part of it is written, chosen or sent by software without a person reading it first; whether the donor is told so, and where; the staff member who answers for that contact point; and how a donor reaches a person from there, in how many steps. Mark every row where software speaks in a human voice or under a human name. For each marked row, draft one sentence of disclosure a donor would see at first contact and, where the row involves a gift, one they would see at the moment of giving. Where my description leaves a cell blank, write "not stated" and do not guess. Finish with the three rows to fix first and the reason for each, using only what I pasted.
What makes it worth trying: In a September survey of 1,020 U.S. adults who had given to charity in the past year, 70.2 percent picked "AI bots portrayed as humans representing a charity" from a list of uses that concern them, and 77 percent called transparency about AI use very important.
The study's two authors work in AI and fundraising, paid for the survey themselves and drew it from an online survey panel, so treat it as a signal, not a measurement. Their recommendations are specific. Two of them: "Disclose at the door, and again at the gift," which I take to mean at first contact and again at the donation, and "Make access to a person a designed feature, not a fallback."
You cannot do either until the contact points are on one page. Writing the description is the real work; the prompt puts it in order and shows the gaps.
Sources: Nathan Chappell and Cherian Koshy, "Donor Perceptions of AI: Third Annual Study," September 2026; Rasheeda Childress, "Donors are wary of AI. A 'human at the helm' policy can help," Chronicle of Philanthropy, October 22, 2026
Decide Where a Person Has to Sign Off
Copy and paste:
Help me draw the line between what software may finish and what a person must approve at my organization. In this message, after these instructions, I am pasting a list of the tasks where we use AI tools or plan to, across programs, finance, fundraising and HR, with the job title of whoever does each task now, what goes wrong for a client, donor, employee or applicant if the output is wrong, and who, if anyone, would notice. Sort the tasks into three groups: software may complete it alone; software may draft it but a named reviewer checks it before it goes out or takes effect; software stays out. Use this test: what happens to a client, donor, employee or applicant if the output is wrong, and whether anyone would catch it. For every task in the middle group, propose which job title should review it, what that person checks, and how long the check should take; I will fill in the names. For every task where the output decides whether someone gets a service, a job, a benefit or money, start it in the third group and tell me what would have to be true to move it to the middle. Where my list does not say, write "not stated" and do not guess. End with a one-page version I can hand to staff.
What makes it worth trying: Pew Research Center asked 3,488 U.S. adults in June how they felt about AI doing eight healthcare tasks, from scheduling to diagnosis. By my count from Pew's chart, for seven of the eight the largest group was open to it "if a human does a final review."
For analyzing medical scans, 60 percent were open with a human review and 6 percent with AI alone. The exception was deciding an insurance claim, where the largest group, 46 percent, was not open to AI doing it at all. Americans, Pew wrote, "largely don't want AI operating without human oversight."
Pew asked about healthcare, not about your intake form or your scholarship committee. I would still bet your clients draw the line in the same place.
Sources: Eileen Yam, Emma Kikuchi and Giancarlo Pasquini, "Americans Are Open to AI in Healthcare, but Want Humans Making Final Calls," Pew Research Center, October 29, 2026
The Repair List — One Page, Thirty Minutes
The draft lease in this issue's second story divides a building in two. The tenant takes the utilities, the cleaning, routine maintenance and non-structural repairs. The county keeps the structure, the roof, the exterior, the plumbing, the wiring, and the heating and cooling.
It is a clean division. One number was not in the memo that went with it, which, Wausau Pilot & Review reported, "does not estimate what the county's repair obligations could cost next year."
Would your own board's page have that number? Your board probably knows who holds the deed or the lease. Has it seen, in one place, what the big parts of the building will cost and when?
Before the meeting. The executive director, or whoever manages the facility, fills in a one-page table for the place where your organization does most of its work. One row for each of six items: roof, heating and cooling, plumbing, electrical, parking lot and walkways, and the largest piece of equipment you depend on, such as a van, a walk-in cooler or a server. Four columns: the year it was installed, if anyone knows; who pays to replace it: you, or the owner under your lease, with the page that says so; a rough replacement cost, from a contractor's ballpark or the last invoice for similar work; and where that money would come from today.
The half hour.
- Read the page (10 minutes). The table goes on the screen. Board members ask questions about facts only. Every "nobody knows" stays on the page in those words.
- Check who pays (8 minutes). If you rent, one board member reads aloud the lease sentences that say who repairs and who replaces. Where the lease is silent, or says the tenant, write "ours" in the row until the owner says otherwise in writing. If you own, every row is yours; use the time to mark the rows with no money behind them.
- Pick one (12 minutes). Ask the person who filled in the table which row is most likely to fail within three years, and take that one. Decide at this meeting where its replacement money will come from, whatever the page says today: a reserve line in next year's budget, a request to the landlord in writing, or one donor you will ask by name. Record the choice in the minutes with a date for the first step.
By video: Share the table as a document everyone can see and have the secretary type the decisions into it.
The trap: Spending the half hour arguing about the cost estimates. A rough number beats no number.
Afterward: The table comes back once a year, updated, at the meeting where the budget is approved.
Sources: Shereen Siewert, Wausau Pilot & Review, November 1, 2026
The Money Nobody Thanks You For
Seven days ago this newsletter was about four organizations and how much warning each could give before it stopped. I asked you to work out your own runway in weeks.
The obvious objection to that assignment is one sentence long: fine, but who is going to give us money for that?
It is the right question, and in my experience the fair answer has usually been "almost no one." Donors give to programs. Foundations give to projects.
Reserves, debt payments and the next boiler come out of whatever is left, and in an organization that spends what it raises on its mission, not much is left.
So I went looking this week for anyone who had put that question on the table, and found three partial answers.
New York's arts council and its partner foundation will pay for a reserve directly, and they release nothing until the board has voted on the rules and the foundation has approved them. That is a funder deciding that a cushion is something worth paying for.
Marathon County's committees approved a lease under which, in the draft, the county keeps a building's roof, wiring and heating for a year while a new nonprofit operates it, at its own cost, on a $1 lease. Whatever the county's reasons, and the one reported was paperwork, the effect is that the expensive risks sit for now with the party that owns the building.
And Tampa Theatre's chief fundraiser said in print, within weeks of a reopening, that she hopes to raise a $22 million endowment to help pay for repairs that have not happened yet. That is someone naming the need before the ceiling comes down.
Look at how far each one falls short. The New York grants will be small next to the budgets they protect; Hudson Hall's is about ten days of spending. The Wisconsin draft says who keeps the roof in 2027, the memo that went with it does not say what that costs, and if the sale follows, the roof changes hands in 2028. The Tampa endowment is a hope with no money reported against it.
But notice what the three have in common. In each case somebody named the unglamorous subject, a reserve, a roof, a repair fund, before it was an emergency.
That is rarer than it should be, and I think I know why. Asking for program money feels like ambition. Asking for reserve money feels like confessing a weakness.
An executive director who tells a funder "we have three weeks of cash and I would like to have three months" worries about how it sounds.
To the person hearing it, it sounds like someone who knows the number. That is the person a careful funder wants to back.
Here is my request. Have your board adopt a reserve policy, as in the first story.
Then pick the one funder or donor who knows your organization best. Tell that person how many weeks of cash you have and how many you want, and ask for a gift toward the difference.
Offer New York's terms as your own: the policy the board adopted, the money held in an interest-bearing account, a final report.
Send this issue along with the request and point to the first story, the one about New York.
New here by way of a forward? Sign up and it comes to you directly, free, on Wednesday mornings.
A reserve with a board vote attached. A roof that a draft lease assigns to someone, in writing, for a year. A hoped-for repair fund, named out loud within weeks of a reopening.
Between now and your next board meeting, fill in the one-page repair list, so the board can take one row and decide where its money comes from.
See you on the 18th.
— Ted
P.S. Has a funder ever paid for your reserve, your debt or your roof? Reply and tell me who it was and how you asked. I will share what worked, without naming anyone.
|
|
Founder and CEO
Risk Alternatives, LLC
202.758.7572 (cell)
Website
Author of Managing Your Nonprofit for Resilience
I help nonprofits thrive by providing practical tools and support to address uncertainty and improve resilience.
|
Did a cool person forward you this email?
Sign up here